Welcome to Main Deck
At Main Deck, located on the serene banks of Lake St in Penn Yan, NY, every meal tells a story. This vibrant eatery boasts an impressive selection of sandwiches, including the renowned Main Deck Burger and scrumptious veggie melt, enticing diners with their fresh flavors and quality ingredients. Patrons rave about the stunning lake views and the inviting ambiance. The blend of casual dining with a touch of sophistication makes it the perfect spot for brunch or a celebratory dinner. With attentive service and a menu that may be limited but thoughtfully curated, Main Deck promises a memorable culinary experience worth savoring.
Main Deck: Reviews & Ratings
Came here for Saturday lunch. I got the Main Deck Burger and it definitely is one of the best burgers in Penn Yan in my opinion. Fries were very good too. The view out across the lake is great. The one small disadvantage here is the menu (especially lunch) is rather small and limited. Was told it’s due to a new chef they got. But the food did taste great. Lunch with no drinks (just water) came out to around 62 plus tip for me and my wife.
We Went to celebrate a birthday. Food was amazing. We started with the steak tartare and the Burrata and both were delicious. For our entrees we had the salmon special and the ribeye steak and both were perfectly cooked! They waitress even brought out cupcakes for our birthday. Definitely will be back next time we are in the area
Gorgeous bar and view. History of Penn Yan Boat industry was well done! Exceptional food. Pro tip: Do not pass on anything the Chef creates with the homemade Pappardelle pasta! Our bartender was a little scattered, but otherwise lovely experience.
First time at Main Deck and the experience was fantastic. The views were awesome from our table, their deck space views were even better. For early May we had gorgeous weather to go out and snapped some photos. The front of the house was super friendly and the server/service was quick and correct. We ordered the smash burger and salmon entrees and couldn’t stop raving about them later in the night. Will be back, and telling all our family and friends to go too!
This place was great. One of my favorite places I ate at while visiting the lakes. Recommend this to family and friends that are planning on making the trip. Not a TON of food options but good variety in the options they have (not gonna get lost reading through a large menu). Wine cocktails were great as well. There was a live band playing while we were there and made evening even more enjoyable
Beautiful location looking out from the main deck onto Keuka Lake especially as the trees are changing color. The food was delicious and we loved the 9.99 lunch options. Our server Kailey was fabulous. Highly recommend this restaurant!
We attended the Feast of Nine Lives dinner and wine pairing and were absolutely blown away by the innovation and creativity that came out of this kitchen. Highly recommend!!!
We had a party of 7 and were greeted immediately by a kind and high energy host. He seated us and poured our waters. We had Vanessa as our server and she was AMAZING!! Her customer service and detailed description of the menu made our experience. The food was great and no one had a bad dish. Medium portion sizes but everyone left full.
Location
-
301 Lake St, Penn Yan, NY 14527, United States Hotline: +1 315-694-7536
If you find yourself in Penn Yan, NY, make sure to explore the delightful offerings at Main Deck, a culinary gem located at 301 Lake St. With a picturesque view of the lake, this establishment serves as a perfect backdrop for enjoying a meal, whether it’s for a special occasion or simply a casual lunch with friends.
Main Deck has quickly garnered attention for its exceptional menu, where every dish is made to impress. Customers have raved about the Main Deck Burger, touted as one of the best in the area, boasting satisfying flavors alongside perfectly cooked fries. Other highlights include the steak tartare and burrata, both inviting starters that set the tone for a wonderful dining experience, as well as entrees like the ribeye steak and salmon special, which leave diners eagerly planning their return visits.
Brunch at Main Deck is also not to be overlooked, thanks to tempting mocktails like the Brunch Breeze and refreshing House Cold Brew, each priced at just $6. For those looking to indulge, the cocktail options, such as the Qkumbertini and Rhubarb Spritz, are well-crafted and priced reasonably, enhancing the overall experience without breaking the bank.
Local patrons appreciate the restaurant's commitment to fresh ingredients and creativity, particularly noted in dishes featuring homemade pappardelle pasta. The ambiance, combined with knowledgeable and friendly staff, ensures that each visit feels warm and welcoming. Moreover, the restaurant’s nod to the history of the Penn Yan boat industry adds a charming touch to your dining experience.
While some reviews mention a limited menu due to a new chef, the quality of food served is consistently praised. The focus seems to be on doing fewer dishes exceptionally well rather than overwhelming diners with a lengthy list of options. As one customer remarked, “Not going to get lost reading through a large menu,” emphasizing the ease and enjoyment of selecting from a curated offering.
Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, planning a fun outing with friends, or simply looking to enjoy good food with a great view, Main Deck promises an experience that will leave you thoroughly satisfied. The scenic backdrop, flavorful dishes, and inviting atmosphere come together to create a restaurant that welcomes you back time and again. Visit them at +1 315-694-7536 to reserve your spot for an unforgettable dining experience.